Rabbit Advocacy Animal Matters
RAN gets FOIA; Finds out more about Iowa Rabbit
October 19, 2014 Rabbit Advocacy Network
The Food Empowerment Project recently filed a Freedom of Information Act request with the USDA’s Food Safety and Inspection Service (FSIS) on behalf of the Rabbit Advocacy Network (RAN). The FOIA request was for a copy of the inspection reports for the slaughterhouse operated by Iowa Rabbit, LLC, the company which provides much of the rabbit meat to Whole Foods. We received a report dating from January 1, 2014, when operations at that slaughterhouse began, through July 22.
RAN’s volunteers have already documented the conditions under which these rabbits, which are sourced from breeders throughout Iowa who respond to ads the company places in newsletters, are raised, which Whole Foods calls humane, but which are massively inconsistent with how rabbit care experts care for their rabbits.
We wanted to find out more about the conditions under which the rabbits–America’s third most popular furry pet–now being slaughtered for sale at Whole Foods stores across the country are dying. We know that these rabbits have their throats slit, after being stunned with a non-penetrating captive bolt gun, and then they are bled out, before they are skinned. We have compiled the research on this method of stunning, and the problems it poses for rabbits here and have found that in many cases, rabbits are still conscious after stunning.
The USDA inspection report, although heavily redacted, provided more information. Even though USDA inspectors are not on site at slaughterhouses to ensure that animals being slaughtered are killed humanely, but to ensure that the meat produced is safe for the public–that’s why they work for the Food Safety and Inspection Service–they do note in their reports a few things that should give people worried about animal welfare pause.
While the report omits slaughter totals, because it is “proprietary information,” it does note the totals of rabbits who died before they could be slaughtered. This includes rabbits who died during transport known as DOA (dead on arrival) and rabbits who died while awaiting slaughter, known as DIY (died in yard).
Because the one federal law that protects livestock being transported to slaughter, the Twenty-Eight Hour Law (which provides minimum safety and care requirements) does not cover poultry, which rabbits are considered by the USDA, it’s not surprising that we should find that rabbits would not survive transport–even just within Iowa. For instance, on a single day in July, 38 rabbits arrived dead in the facility.
In addition, baby rabbits, called “fryers” by the industry, arrive at the slaughterhouse, and may sometimes wait for a few days to a week before they are slaughtered. (The parents, after years of breeding the babies, once they are used up are slaughtered as “roasters.”) Again, there are no minimum standards for their care while they await death so it shouldn’t surprise us that many perish, in the same overcrowded transport cages in which they arrived, before their slaughter day arrives. One March day, 38 rabbits died at Iowa LLC while in their cages.
Finally, quite a few rabbits in our report were classified by the USDA inspector as “condemned,” which means that they were determined to be too sick for consumption. Most days there were at least a couple of rabbits who were condemned; these rabbits were then killed, and their bodies discarded, because the conditions in which they were raised or transported were too brutal.
This inspection report, even though it was not intended to highlight animal welfare problems, clearly shows major problems with Whole Foods allegedly “humane” standards when it comes to rabbit meat. Rabbits are not protected under the federal Humane Methods of Slaughter Act, and, since the USDA inspectors who inspect the slaughterhouses are not present in order to monitor animal welfare, there is no way to ensure that these animals do not suffer horrifically leading up to and during slaughter. Furthermore, Whole Foods has chosen to use suppliers and processors in states with “Ag Gag” laws (laws which criminalize the recording of undercover videos showing animal cruelty), which means that private citizens have no way of finding out what really happens during slaughter. Whole Foods’ only response to months’ of questioning from the public and the media has been to reiterate that their new standards for rabbits are “humane.”
What we do know from all of the evidence that we have uncovered is that the rabbits being sold for food at Whole Foods Market are not being humanely raised nor killed. The animal lovers whom Rabbit Advocacy Network represents are asking all animal lovers to join us in our fight to stop Whole Foods from adding one more animal to their meat cases.
September 15, 2015 update: Whole Foods Market announces the end of rabbit meat sales. On its website it states “the pilot ultimately revealed the sales volume did not justify the continuation or expansion of the pilot to a national program. We expect all remaining product will be sold-through by January, 2016."
“As always, Whole Foods Market’s knowledgeable in-house butchers are happy to provide suggestions and recommendations for customers seeking lean alternatives like quail, pheasant, buffalo/bison, lamb or venison.”
Comment: Whole Foods did not expect or acknowledge the enormous public backlash when it announced the pilot project in June 2014. It has been under fire previously for false advertising when it was found they deceived their customers by selling unlabeled genetically modified products, while claiming “Nothing Artificial, Ever.” This company is unethical, socially irresponsible, misleads shoppers about its support of small farmers, and lies about humane standards, among other practices. It’s all about the bottom line and the only reason rabbit meat was discontinued is because of the lack of sales. Public pressure and boycotts work.
Find out more about Whole Foods: http://michaelbluejay.com/misc/wholefoods.html